The quantity of Black Friday print flyers in this past Thursday’s (11/24) newspaper held steady again this year with 32 local & national print flyers compared to 33 last year in my local newspaper, the Foster Daily Democrat. What was disappointing this year was the lack of interactive ads as compared to last year, be it mobile coupons, text programs, 2d codes, offers via Twitter or Facebook, mobile app downloads, etc.. Last year there were only “two print flyers” each with one QR code. This year there were only “five print flyers” with QR codes, three flyers each with one QR code, one flyer with two QR codes, and one with 5 QR codes. Or a total of 10 pages of the 608 total combined print flyer pages had a QR code for a whopping 1.6%. A BUST on adoption of interactive consumer print engagement to say the least!
Before I ask why, here are a few other stats of my unscientific survey: new this year were national flyers offering their own Smart Phone App to download, and four chains using WEB-IDs or SKUs for each of their products within the flyers that consumer can input while on the chain’s web site via their smart phone or PC. Only four promoted an opt-in texting program, eleven noted to follow them on Twitter, fifteen noted to follow them on Face Book, and 30 of the 32 listed their web address. To summarize, of the seven marketing channels tabulated (mobile app, QR codes, twitter, Face Book, SMS texting, web ids, & web Urls) not one advertiser used all seven and only two of the 32 promoted via five channels within their print flyers.
According to IBM Coremetrics Benchmark™ metrics we know smart phones are being used as the following stats were collected over the past 48 hours;
“ Mobile shopping also remains strong this Black Friday:
- Mobile Traffic: The number of consumers using a mobile device to visit a retailer’s site is holding firm at 17.04 percent.
- Mobile Shopping: The number of consumers using their mobile device to make a purchase is holding steady at 9.51 percent.
- Mobile Devices: iPhone continues to lead all mobile device traffic at 6.58 percent, followed by Android at 5.20 percent and iPad at 4.71 percent.”
“As part of IBM’s Smarter Commerce initiative, IBM’s online retail benchmark study reveals the following trends as of 12:00 am PST Saturday/ 11/26,2011:
CONSUMER SPENDING INCREASES:
Strong Thanksgiving shopping carried over into Black Friday with online sales increasing 24.3 percent annually.
THE MOBILE BARGAIN HUNTER:
Black Friday witnessed the arrival of the mobile deal seeker who embraced their devices as a research tool for in-store and online bargains. Mobile traffic increased to 14.3 percent on Black Friday 2011 compared to 5.6 percent in 2010.
MOBILE SALES:
Sales on mobile devices surged to 9.8 percent from 3.2 percent year over year.
THE APPLE SHOPPER:
Mobile shopping was led by Apple, with the iPhone and iPad ranking one and two for consumers shopping on mobile devices (5.4 percent and 4.8 percent respectively). Android came in third at 4.1 percent. Collectively iPhone and iPad accounted for 10.2 percent of all online retail traffic on Black Friday.
THE IPAD FACTOR:
Shoppers using the iPad led to more retail purchases more often per visit than other mobile devices with conversion rates reaching 4.6 percent compared to 2.8 percent for overall mobile devices.
SURGICAL SHOPPING GOES MOBILE:
Mobile shoppers demonstrated a laser focus that surpassed that of other online shoppers with a 41.3 percent bounce rate on mobile devices versus online shopping rates of 33.1 percent.
THE SOCIAL INFLUENCE:
Shoppers referred from Social Networks generated 0.53 percent of all online sales on Black Friday. Facebook led the pack, accounting for 75 percent of all traffic from social networks.
SOCIAL MEDIA CHATTER:
Boosted by a 110 percent increase in discussion volume compared to 2010, top discussion topics on social media sites immediately before Friday showed a focus on the part of consumers to share tips on how to avoid the rush. Topics included out-of-stock concerns, waiting times and parking, and a spike in positive sentiment around Cyber-Monday sales.”
“This year marked Thanksgiving’s emergence as the first big spending day of the 2011 holiday season with a record number of consumers shifting their focus from turkey to tablets and the search for the best deals,” said John Squire, Chief Strategy Officer, IBM Smarter Commerce. “This momentum continued into Black Friday where the big winners were those retailers that delivered a smarter commerce experience with compelling, relevant deals that people could easily access from their channel of choice.”
The stats IBM did not tabulate and unfortunately no one else will easily tabulate are the net effect of this year’s Black Friday’s print flyers had on retails sales, I believe they were significant.
Back in December, 2009, I wrote a blog titled, “2010 the Year for Interactive Print” where I stated, “It won’t be long before an advertiser says, why would we print another piece without an interactive or digital connection?” As much as I missed the mark for 2010, and for all we have heard about Twitter, Facebook and 2d Url QR codes so far in 2011, I expected to see more retailers using them in this week’s Black Friday newspaper, but we didn’t. What does my little survey again indicate? Missed opportunity? More education needed? Or is the effort in making print interactive not worth it?
I believe retailers missed an opportunity again to build consumer opt-in lists for subsequent text and internet offers delivered directly to consumer’s cell phones. Today still only some of the larger retail stores such as Target, JC Penney & Macy’s have text alert programs. From an educational stand point, opt-in programs are just one of the many proven interactive methods more retailers need to know about. Technology wise many interactive tools for consumer touch points are available today for advertiser & retailers to utilize as part of the media mix.
From the position of a Mobile Marketing Technology provider, looking on the bright side, there is much room for growth and education in applying integrated interactive solutions. Wherever the interactive growth is now in 2012, I believe Print Flyers will again continue strong with or without consumer engagement methods. Care to guess where the number will be within next year’s Thanksgivings day paper?
By Roger Belanger
Director, GossRSVP
Please send your comments to roger.belager@gossinternational.com